Rugby League Dec 07, 2025

Brian Carney's Ashes reflections: Shaun Wane and the burden of his own benchmark for England

👤
By Admin
Sports Journalist
Brian Carney's Ashes reflections: Shaun Wane and the burden of his own benchmark for England

Shaun Wane's own words have come home to roost.

Wane in February 2020 said: "If I don't get to a World Cup final and win, it's a disaster. We haven't beaten Australia for a long time and I'm embarrassed by that. And if we don't beat them, it's on me."

In the end, Wane didn't just set the bar, he fashioned the trapdoor beneath it. Those were his words, not anyone else's.

And by his own measure, the two most important campaigns of his six years in charge have been nothing short of catastrophic.

England's home World Cup, played in 2022 not 2021 because of Covid, was supposed to be the moment rugby league reconnected with a wider domestic audience. The draw was deliberately kind: no Australia, no New Zealand until the final. All roads led to Old Trafford.

Except, of course, England didn't make it there.

They were beaten in the semis by Samoa- a Samoan side England had blitzed in the tournament's opening game.

Many good judges feel it was a semi-final that was there for the taking. England went in as favourites and came unstuck in a big way.

By Wane's 2020 logic, not winning the final would have been a "disaster". What words would one use to describe not even making it?

Fast forward to 2025 and Australia return for the first Ashes series in years.

A golden chance again for the game on these shores to fire up the sporting public's imagination. Instead, the Kangaroos left with a clean sweep and England barely left clutching the usual consolation prize of "effort".

Three defeats, three below-par performances, just two tries in 240 minutes of rugby league. If Wane was embarrassed in 2020 about England not beating Australia in so long, he must be incandescent now.

I watched Reece Walsh sign autographs pitchside an hour after the final whistle on Saturday. The Australians, the team I'm told the English love to hate, had won the hearts and minds of supporters over here.

England's rugby league team is more than a collection of individuals sent out to win a game. They represent the sport.

For whatever reason they admirably welcomed cameras into camp for a behind-the-scenes documentary yet appeared to be kept from the cameras, microphones and adoring fans at other times. This is just my perception. No doubt a series review will determine if this was indeed the case.

The question now falls to the RFL: back him or sack him. Wane is contracted until the end of 2026, taking in next year's World Cup in Australia and Papua New Guinea. He hasn't coached a club side since 2018, an eternity in rugby league terms.

In November 2024 Wane expressed a desire to return to club coaching at some point in the future, admitting he missed preparing regularly for matches and hinting at excess capacity: "I feel like I'm under-selling myself".

The likes of Paul Rowley, Matt Peet, Willie Peters, Michael Maguire and Brian McDermott are all names likely to come to the fore in conversations about Wane's future.

Wane's prickly dismissal of the Man of Steel award did little to help his cause. Asked about Jake Connor, the 2025 winner, Wane waved it away: "I don't know who picks it and it never comes into my consideration."

You don't have to pick Jake Connor to respect the game's most prestigious individual award. But publicly diminishing it? That's poor politics.

How do the RFL market an honour their own England coach treats with contempt? There are more than enough knowledgeable rugby league fans here. I've met and spoken to them at Wembley, Headingley and in recent days at events in Hull, Keighley and Cumbria.

I'm echoing their sentiments. They demand more than a "credit in the bank" explanation when selecting players to represent them.

At times, Wane's passion seems to have curdled into obstinacy. He talks about "English grit" as if it were a secret weapon, but grit without craft is just friction.

His side looked rigid, predictable, and joyless. For a man who once demanded England "play without fear", his team look paralysed by it.

When asked recently about 2026, Wane said: "I don't believe I'm the right man to coach England at the World Cup - I know it."

He "knew" plenty of things, of course. He "knew" the out-of-form players he picked would deliver. They didn't. He "knew" his spine was right - until he changed three of those four positions after one game.

Now, it's the RFL who must "know".

Do they double down on loyalty, or acknowledge that the "disaster" Wane once warned of has already arrived and, by his own admission, it's on him?

Because in sport, as in politics, when your own words become your best critic, the argument is usually over.

There are of course much broader issues at play in the game over here. Including their focus on the international game the RFL must decide if more of the same will deliver different results and if they are happy with keeping their fingers crossed for that.

The alternative is to draw a line in the sand and make this period the cliff edge we refused to get pushed over. The next few months will be telling.

Tags:

rugby-league news id:13468071

Share this article

Related Posts

Wigan 16-34 Huddersfield: Six-try Giants stun Warriors to dash perfect Super League record

Wigan 16-34 Huddersfield: Six-try Giants stun Warriors to dash perfect Super League record

Struggling Huddersfield produced a sensational performance to defeat Betfred Super League leaders Wigan 34-16 at the Brick Community Stadium.Giants sa...

Kalyn Ponga defects from Australia to New Zealand ahead of Rugby League World Cup after State of Origin eligibility shake-up

Kalyn Ponga defects from Australia to New Zealand ahead of Rugby League World Cup after State of Origin eligibility shake-up

The International Rugby league Board has approved Kalyn Ponga's application to switch Tier 1 eligibility from Australia to New Zealand ahead of the Ru...

Challenge Cup: Latest results with Wigan Warriors, Leeds Rhinos, Hull KR and St Helens among teams in action

Challenge Cup: Latest results with Wigan Warriors, Leeds Rhinos, Hull KR and St Helens among teams in action

Goalkeeper Cox shutting out noise about futureLatest from Your Site' Dan Long:Brentford goalkeeper Matt Cox - who is currently on loan...

30 years of Super League: Pundits remember their favourite moments including Rob Burrow magic, that Jack Welsby moment, and a Good Friday brawl

30 years of Super League: Pundits remember their favourite moments including Rob Burrow magic, that Jack Welsby moment, and a Good Friday brawl

The Your Site Rugby League team have spent 30 years following the highs, the lows, the jubilation, the heartbreak we see each week in Super League.The...

Castleford Tigers 40-28 Bradford Bulls: Jason Qareqare hat-trick helps Ryan Carr's side to second win of season to start Super League's 30th birthday

Castleford Tigers 40-28 Bradford Bulls: Jason Qareqare hat-trick helps Ryan Carr's side to second win of season to start Super League's 30th birthday

Castleford Tigers scored seven tries to pull off a 40-28 victory over Bradford Bulls in round six of Super League at The OneBore Stadium.The clash bet...

Hull KR 52-10 St Helens: Mikey Lewis and Joe Burgess secure hat-tricks as Robins run riot against Saints

Hull KR 52-10 St Helens: Mikey Lewis and Joe Burgess secure hat-tricks as Robins run riot against Saints

Hull KR scored nine tries in a 52-10 demolition of St Helens Sewell in round six of Super League as Sewell Group Craven Park.As Super League's 30th bi...